DAILY SCIENCE

The case to keep using fossil fuels keeps getting weaker
Fossil fuels, long thought to give a high energy return on energy investment, are actually no better than renewables, and are in some cases worse.
July 25, 2019

A new study published in Nature Energy finds that fossil fuels aren’t nearly as efficient as people have long believed them to be. Plus, as they get harder to extract, their energy cost is going up and renewables start to make more energy sense.

Researchers from the University of Leeds looked the energy return on investment, the ratio of the amount of energy a fuel will produce compared to how much energy it takes to extract.

For decades, fossil fuels have been considered to be winners over renewables in terms of EROI. Estimates for the EROI for oil, gas, and coal typically come in at over 25:1, the researchers write. Meanwhile, the EROI for renewables is usually calculated to be less than 10:1.

However, those ratios are calculated at the primary stage where the fuel is first extracted and is in its original form. In reality, oil, natural gas and coal require energy to be converted into their final useful forms such as gasoline and electricity.

Paul E. Brockway and his colleagues calculate that when this transformation process is taken into account, the EROI for fossil fuels drops to around 6:1. This is the same as the EROI for solar power. For electricity, the EROI for fossil fuels was as low as 3:1.

The researchers used data spanning 1995–2011 from the International Energy Agency and Exiobase. Their calculations showed that over the 16-year period, the EROI for fossil fuels went down by 23 percent. The ratio is set to decline further as easily accessible fossil fuels get depleted and there is an increase in the use of unconventional fuels like shale gas.

Source: Paul E. Brockway et al. Estimation of global final-stage energy-return-on-investment for fossil fuels with comparison to renewable energy sources. Nature Energy, 2019.

Photo: nattanan23, pixabay

What to Read Next

Get the latest sustainability science delivered to your inbox every week

You have successfully signed up

Your Donation Will Be Doubled

From now until December 31st as part of a national campaign to support nonprofit news

Share This

Share This Article