How do you heal a forest?
In the time it takes you to read this story, more than 5 acres of rainforest just in the Amazon will likely have vanished, the equivalent of around 3 soccer fields. This means that as people scramble to stave off the worst version of the planet’s 6th great extinction, not to mention climate change, there is the pressing question of what to do with all these logged forests.Scientists toiling in a Malaysian jungle have emerged with some new answers. By tracking changes in more than 1,600 species of plants and animals, they have discovered forest ecosystems undergo sudden shifts when logging reaches certain thresholds.
Their findings suggest that even places with some logging could be worthy of protections similar to untouched forests. And it points to which strategies might best help restore a logged forest’s health.
“While pristine forests are shrinking worldwide, this doesn’t mean all hope is lost,” said Robert Ewers, an ecologist at the Imperial College London who led the new research. “There are other forests we can protect to preserve biodiversity.”
Plenty of research has looked at how logging affects an ecosystem. But that work usually only looks at a small slice of the overall picture. An ecosystem is staggering in its complexity, none more so than a raucous tropical jungle. To capture how all the inhabitants react to an intrusion by chainsaws would be an epic undertaking.
But that’s what scientists tried to do at an experimental research forest in Borneo. Different parts of the forest there have been subjected to different levels of abuse. Some have been left untouched. Other areas have been lightly logged. Still others were clearcut and stripped of virtually all vegetation.
Over a decade, researchers combed these landscapes again and again—more than 125 times. They identified nearly 5,000 different species. Of those, people spotted 1,681 of these species at least five times, providing enough data to create a statistical model of how those individual species reacted to changes in the forest.
The list of the types of species is a testament to the staggering richness of a rainforest: 590 plants, 88 mammals, 161 birds, 9 reptiles, 42 amphibians, 26 fish, 263 beetles, 199 butterflies, 130 ants and 33 spiders. They ranged in size from the 3000-kilogram Bornean elephant to a beetle weighing less than a grain of rice.
The scientists sifted through the data looking for two critical points: The level of logging when there is the first change in the likelihood that they will find an individual species, and the point at which that likelihood changed the fastest.
They found that populations started changing even with the lightest touch. As the first trees began to fall, nearly a quarter of the species underwent a change in how frequently they were found, the scientists reported in mid-July in Nature.
Additional species showed signs of reacting until logging removed about 30% of the forest’s biomass, at which point the number of species being altered leveled off. That held steady until more than 80% of the forest was gone. Then a whole new set of species began showing signs being affected by logging.
This pattern, say the scientists, suggests that while forests are very sensitive to logging, they also have the potential to adjust or rebound on their own if less than 30% of a forest is logged. That means the kinds of protections used for unlogged forests, such as wildlife refuges, could also work in places that have been logged just a little bit. The threshold could also serve as a benchmark for logging projects that claim to be ecologically sustainable.
“Pristine forests will always be the ideal, but there shouldn’t be a binary view of what’s worth preserving and what’s not,” said co-author Will Pearse, and evolutionary ecologist at Imperial College London. “Some degree of logging may always be necessary, and while these forests are not the same as pristine ones, at certain thresholds they can still sustain themselves as functioning ecosystems.”
The findings also offer a clue about what kinds of forests could benefit most from restoration efforts, and how much restoration is warranted. In that middle zone of logging, there may not be much gained by worked to move a place from having lost 60% of its forest to 40%.
By contrast, the findings point “to where restoration projects would get the best return to investment,” said Cristina Banks-Leite, an Imperial College London ecologist who was involved in the research. “Changes in biodiversity are faster below 30% and above 70% biomass loss, which suggests that any improvement on habitat in these areas would lead to dramatic changes in biodiversity.”
So perhaps the least damaged and most damaged places deserve attention for that hard work of healing.
Ewers, et. al. “Thresholds for adding degraded tropical forest to the conservation estate.” Nature. July 17, 2024.
Image: UnSplash







