Nonprofit journalism dedicated to creating a Human Age we actually want to live in.

Note: This article is from Conservation Magazine, the precursor to Anthropocene Magazine. The full 14-year Conservation Magazine archive is now available here.

Imperfect Copies

June 6, 2022

Animals created through nuclear transfer aren’t quite perfect replicas of their rare or endangered donors, because they also contain the mitochondrial DNA from their egg donors. And so using interspecies nuclear transfer to duplicate an endangered species raises an interesting philosophical question. As David Ehrenfeld, a biologist at Rutgers University, put it in a 2006 essay: “[I]s a cloned animal, whose mitochondrial DNA is at least partly from the egg donor species, a true copy of the species we are trying to conserve; and does it matter if it is . . . ?” It’s a provocative question, but in the long run, scientists could keep the foreign DNA from spreading through a wild population by breeding the animals carefully. Since mitochondrial DNA is inherited entirely from the mother, all that researchers would need to do is prevent the female offspring of female clones from having kittens. Male offspring of female clones, and all offspring of male clones, could reproduce freely. ❧

—Emily Anthes

Photo: Northern leopard frog ©Brian Gratwicke

<< Return to “Ditto”

What to Read Next